To: polly.toynbee@guardian.co.uk
Re: "Economic forces" are located in man's animal nature
Date: Friday, 21 April 06

Great stuff, Polly, in today's comment ("Throw open the books so that we can see what everyone earns") but please allow me to give you a short but necessary lesson in evolutionary anthropology.
 
Despite all the lip service paid to Charles Darwin, we still implicitly assume ourselves to be fallen angels, who succumb to temptation and corruption, thus creating the absurd wealth and income differentials characteristic of our society.
 
The truth is that we are animals, Earth's Greatest (aspiring) Ape; only far too many of us (pressed and cajoled by our free-amoral market economy) are not aspiring to anything other than what our primitive animal nature (which evolved over millions of years) drives us to in the struggle for survival and advantage in the socio-economic environment (which for us has now replaced the natural environment - a very important point that!). It used to be brawn, bananas or the like, but now it's MONEY, which is by far the most important and versatile form of power in the socio-economic environment.
 
Like you, Polly, I too want a more just, humane and above all - since everything else depends on it - sustainable society, but in order to get there we have to understand that the existing socio-economic order is deeply rooted in our primitive animal nature. How could it be otherwise, in view of our animal origins? But it is not just Christian fundamentalists who are loath to face up to it. This is where so-called "economic forces" are located, and where we have to look in order to change them - which we must, if your species is to survive.
 
Links: